Skip to content
25 October 1927 · 25 October 2027
Terceira Classe
25 October 2026

Ninety-nine years

Ninety-nine years ago, on Tuesday, 25 October 1927, the Principessa Mafalda sank in the Atlantic off the coast of Bahia, Brazil.

She had left Genoa fourteen days earlier. She carried 1,259 people, and most of them travelled in third class. They were emigrants: Italians, for the most part, and also Spaniards, Yugoslavs, Arabs, Swiss. They were going to Brazil, to Uruguay and, above all, to Argentina. They carried what fitted in a trunk and a simple idea, which many families summed up in a phrase: to make America. To work, send money home, one day go back.

Trunks, bundles and suitcases on the quay, beside a ship’s hull. The port is not identified.
Trunks, bundles and suitcases on the quay, beside a ship’s hull. The port is not identified.Museu da Imigração do Estado de São Paulo / Arquivo Público do Estado de São Paulo

At a quarter past five in the afternoon the propeller shaft broke and the sea began to come in through the stern. The sun set at 6.19. The rest happened in the dark: the lights that failed on board, the lifeboats that left too full or capsized, people clinging to pieces of wood, people waiting in the water for the ships that were on their way. The captain, Simone Gulì, stayed on board.

The Principessa Mafalda at 6.30 p.m. on 25 October 1927, listing and sinking stern first, photographed from the deck of the Alhena.
The Principessa Mafalda at 6.30 p.m. on 25 October 1927, listing and sinking stern first, photographed from the deck of the Alhena.Diário da Manhã, Recife, 30.11.1927 · Hemeroteca Digital Brasileira

314 people died, by the official figure. Among them were babies a few months old. On the list of those the freighter Alhena took to Rio de Janeiro, someone noted by hand that two passengers had lost their husbands that night and were asking to go back to Italy. A girl of sixteen named Josefina lost her parents and two brothers and was raised by her aunt and uncle in Argentina. Assunta, twenty-one, saw her brother fall into the sea and could never again bear to look at a river. Oreste, who could not swim, survived clinging to a piece of wood and spent his life not wanting to talk about it.

The note that closes the list of survivors brought by the Alhena: passengers number 24 and 25 «perderam seus maridos» (lost their husbands) and asked to go back to Italy.
The note that closes the list of survivors brought by the Alhena: passengers number 24 and 25 «perderam seus maridos» (lost their husbands) and asked to go back to Italy.Arquivo Nacional, BR RJANRIO OL.0.RPV.PRJ.22463

Those who survived arrived with nothing: what they had brought stayed at the bottom of the sea. They landed in Rio de Janeiro, in Bahia, in Recife, went on to São Paulo, Buenos Aires, Montevideo, and began from nothing the life they had crossed the ocean for. Many chose never to speak of that night again.

Women survivors on Ilha das Flores, Rio de Janeiro, around the Italian ambassador’s wife, marked with an X.
Women survivors on Ilha das Flores, Rio de Janeiro, around the Italian ambassador’s wife, marked with an X.Revista da Semana, Rio de Janeiro, 5.11.1927 · Hemeroteca Digital Brasileira

My great-grandmother, Rosa Forner, was 24 and held her one-year-old son Enrico in her arms. She was with her sister, Maria Luigia, and four children. All seven survived. Ten years later, in 1937, Rosa gave a daughter the name of the ship that had nearly killed her: Mafalda.

Rosa Forner Miotto, 1903–1986. Photograph from 1976, digitally restored by the author.
Rosa Forner Miotto, 1903–1986. Photograph from 1976, digitally restored by the author.Miotto family collection

For a long time the shipwreck was met with silence. The plaque that remembers it today in Genoa says it was long hidden by the responsibilities of the Fascist regime and of the shipping company. In Brazil almost no one remembers it. But in thousands of families in Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay and Italy that night is still present, sometimes in a name, sometimes in a silence, sometimes in a trunk that never arrived.

The plaque in memory of the shipwreck at the Galata Museo del Mare in Genoa, put up on 25 October 2012.
The plaque in memory of the shipwreck at the Galata Museo del Mare in Genoa, put up on 25 October 2012.Galata Museo del Mare, Genoa

Today is a day to remember them: those who never arrived, and those who arrived and began again.

Share

← All notes